Where to Get the Best Thanksgiving Pies From Montgomery County Top Bakers

Christine Tarlecki

By Christine Tarlecki

We all say Thanksgiving is about the turkey…but really, it’s all about the PIE. These are just a few of our favorite bakeries in Montgomery County that bake up the best.

Clara’s Custom Cakes (located at 130 West Main Street in Collegeville, 484-854-0080) focuses on extraordinary cakes and pies for the customer who knows their desserts. Call for some delicious holiday rolls like pumpkin, cakes, and pies for your Thanksgiving table.

Beverly’s Pastry Shop (located at 322 E. High Street in Pottstown) is taking orders via email: send an email with what you would like. There’s a huge array to choose from; classic pies like cherry, blueberry, apple, or pumpkin; specialty pies like bourbon pecan, chocolate silk, salted caramel apple crumb, and chocolate peanut butter. They are also offering cakes, both gluten-free and regular; cupcakes in GF, vegan, and regular; cheesecakes with a variety of flavors, and dessert shot glasses like strawberry cheesecake and key lime. Gluten-free shot glasses and pumpkin rolls also available. If you need fresh rolls and buns to accompany your Thanksgiving meal, Beverly’s has them too. Order via email: Subject: Turkey Day Order and our email: beverlyspastryshop@gmail.com.

Corropolese Bakery has got pies for your holiday! Order ahead and pick up on Thanksgiving. Coconut custard, pumpkin, cherry, apple, apple crumb, caramel apple walnut, peach, pecan, blueberry, Boston cream, chocolate mousse, and lemon meringue are available to order. They also have a fun Thanksgiving Turkey Cupcake Cake (Feeds 16, and is available at Audubon location only) and a yummy Thanksgiving Cookie (12” Cookie is available at all locations). Ordering ahead is recommended, and they will be open Thanksgiving 9am-1pm.

Corropolese Bakery has several locations:  

  • 2014 Old Arch Road in Norristown, 610-275-6664
  • 29 Kugler Road in Limerick, 610-495-8331
  • 2809 Egypt Road in Audubon, 610-630-3844.

Kriebel’s Bakery Café (located at 3140 Ridge Pike in Eagleville, 484-679-1406) has pies for your Thanksgiving dinner. Call for your reservation of delicious pies, they have a wide varieties of great desserts.

And you can order pies from Manna to help out local food banks!

*Please check with each bakery regarding availability, hours, curbside pickup, mask requirements, social distancing, and other COVID-19 protocols. Please respect the establishments that you visit.


Christine Tarlecki is a local food and lifestyle writer, seeking out the best bites in the area and writing about them. She pens an award-winning food & lifestyle blog, Engchik Eats, at engchik.blogspot.com and teaches small business social media marketing classes. And don’t miss the new Engchik Eats #podcast at https://anchor.fm/engchikeatsbychristinet Christine can be reached at engchik@gmail.com and under @engchik on all social media. #LocalLove

Want a feature written about your business or need social media to highlight a new business or menu item? Email Christine today for the best coverage around!